Occupied Lands of the Cheyenne and Arapahoe Front Range Colorado Rockies
By Jennifer Murnan
American politics have been increasingly controlled by the wealthy elite. Oligarchy, government by a few for corrupt and selfish purposes is already present in the system. Every day the political situation worsens it follows that our communities must open conversations on how to resist further political movement toward increasingly dictatorial/fascist governance.
What kind of regime will we get when power is seized by a misogynistic con man want to be dictator whose mob is white Christian nationalist and a transhumanist mega mogul whose bloody hands are on the atomic bomb of all propaganda machines, social media? The answer – We are in the process of finding out.
When the 2024 election results were final, I spent a day and a night immobilized. My only thought was, “We are really in for it now.” And that – takes a while – to sink in. Thirty-six hours later I headed straight to the library and grabbed a stack of books looking for information to answer these questions:
What is fascism? Is this fascism?
What are the origins of totalitarianism?
How can I, my family, and my community combat fascism?
I decided I didn’t have any interest in reading alone, so I enlisted my mom, who is fearless in pursuit of the truth and in her love of human and greater-than-human community. We had deep conversations concerning the library books I discovered and read together. We have also comforted each other through sleepless nights and nightmares as we worked through the list and understood more about our communal plight. In one of my mother’s nightmares, a faceless orange blob, a repulsive infant, demanded attention and endlessly to be fed.
I also found a fellow traveler on this educational reading journey in my good friend and comrade, Boris. We are still digesting and discussing The Origins of Totalitarianism. I am reading this classic in English, and he is reading it in the author’s German translation. These conversations with my mom and with Boris have resulted in three book recommendations.
The Origins of Totalitarianism by Hanna Arendt
Preparing for War by Bradley Onishi
How to Stand Up to a Dictator by Maria Ressa
All three authors survived encounters with totalitarian regimes. Hanna was Jewish and was forced to flee the Nazis twice, once in 1933 to Paris and again in 1941 to the US. Bradley is a scholar of religion who spent eleven years in the White Christian nationalist movement. Maria spent years as an investigative reporter before becoming the CEO, co-founder and president of Rappler, the Philippines’ top digital- only news site. Maria and Rappler were targeted relentlessly by the Duterte Dictatorship. All three authors are excellent in their analysis of the destructive forces they have experienced, studied and describe, at the same time that they are of the culture of civilization which has ensnared us all. Here is a snapshot of the insights and information that these authors have given us as I revisit my initial questions.
Is this fascism? The United States is sliding into a political structure that bears hallmarks of fascism and totalitarianism. Of course, this development is consistent with the nation’s racist imperialist history. However, the fascists/ totalitarian regimes of the Nazi’s and of Stalin are products of the last century. Sadly, our condition has worsened.
What is fascism? A centralized autocratic government led by a dictator characterized by severe social and economic regimentation that forcibly and violently represses any opposition to totalitarian rule.
What are the origins of fascism?
Leaving aside the historical aspects, these are some of the societal and social conditions that were and are exploited by fascists.
Fascism and totalitarianism are supremely patriarchal. As such, these forces must engage in endlessly waging war against the enemies created by a meta narrative. Totalitarianism seeks absolute domination on a global scale.
Totalitarians utilize fabricated meta-narratives that glorify the return to a non-existent mythic past. Additionally, these narratives drive action toward a predestined future.
In the US, the government takeover is following the meta narrative of White Christian Nationalism and is profoundly racist. “In fact, racism is the foundation of White Christian nationalism, the load-bearing portion that supports the structure and weight of the entire project.” Bradley Onishi Preparing for War. The White Christian nationalist movement sees the US as God’s “City on the Hill”. The nation is chosen by God to bring the kingdom of the lord to the world. The US must return to its patriarchal white Christian origins to fulfill this God-given mission. The cross and flag have for decades appeared prominently side by side on many white evangelical pulpits.
When fascists first come into power their first mission is to eliminate all political and intellectual opposition. Rule by terror and fear follow the initial purge.
“Without concentration camps, without the undefined fear they inspire and the very well-defined training they offer in totalitarian domination, which can nowhere else be fully tested with all of its most radical possibilities, a totalitarian state can neither inspire its nuclear troops with fanaticism nor maintain a whole people in complete apathy.” — Hanna Arendt The Origins of Totalitarianism, p. 587-588
Classic fascist leaders Hitler and Stalin were masters of sowing confusion, doubt, and division not only in the population, but within their inner circles. No relationships that could challenge their authority and absolute monopoly over power and control were allowed to form. Isolation and loneliness are conditions that make humans vulnerable to attack and susceptible to belief in conspiracy theories as well as other forms of authoritarian control.
“The effectiveness of this kind of propaganda demonstrates one of the chief characteristics of modern masses. They do not believe in anything visible, in the reality of their own experience; they do not trust their eyes and ears but only their imaginations, which may be caught by anything that is at once universal and consistent in itself. What convinces masses are not facts, and not even invented facts, but only the consistency of the system of which they are presumably a part.” — Arendt, p. 462-3
In the US, the current government takeover has been in the works for 60 years with racist cultural roots that are much older. The gasoline poured on the fires of autocratic tendencies in the US and globally has been social media manipulation. Hate is the fuel for totalitarian movements and hate is the best-selling emotional content on the net.
Here in a nutshell is the rotten core and endgame of totalitarianism:
“For power left to itself can achieve nothing but more power, and violence administered for power’s (and not for law’s) sake turn into a destructive principle that will not stop until there is nothing left to violate.”
— Arendt, p. 184, addressing Imperialism
How can I, my family, my community combat destructive autocratic, totalitarian, oligarchical governmental takeovers? We can begin by seeking knowledge. The first chapter in How to Stand Up to a Dictator is titled -The Golden Rule Make the Choice to Learn. From the title on How to Stand Up to a Dictator is a practicum on how to be an effective resistor, individually and communally. All of us are in unique circumstances and yet, Maria Ressa’s principles for resistance, like CPR principles, can be universally applied.
An endnote. My mother’s nightmares ended with one final dream. All the women in our family were present to comfort reassure and support one blond haired blue eyed and very confused baby girl. The circle was whole and healthy, even the women that had been problematic in life were well.
There was no strife, only good will and love and purpose prevailed.